Perhaps the only difference is the fact the latter has a romantic side, but still, they are too comparable. Should we give disneys coco a chance or is it a book of. Mar 15, 2017 the book of life comparisons are a little too close for comfort, they say. This is a comparison to see the similarities between coco and the book of life. Dec 09, 2017 similarities between coco and the book of life. The next similarity sees both protagonists manolo and miguel being. Okay, so i dont remember the score for the book of life. Coco, in comparison, went above and beyond with vr, introducing the movies signature song remember me on dancing with the stars, and. It works in the story, but i tend to enjoy the more realistic style of pixars animation in coco. At least the book of life had angry gods to keep things interesting.
Pixar has a way of just making beautiful scenes in their movies and this happens again in coco. However, while there are superficial similarities in the same way that two movies set at christmas would be expected to share certain images, the plots are divergent. Is the new pixar movie a ripoff of the book of life. Its not fair for me to compare these films directly considering the studios, the budgets, and the 3 year time difference. The year is 2014 and a really good little animated movie called the book of life is released. Prior to release, my two concerns with the movie was that it would be a heartless pixar version of the book of life, and that disney would take advantage and exploit the hispanic culture in a distasteful way. Nov 22, 2017 the book of life is a love story that explores the importance of bravery and confronting ones own fears, while coco is a coming of age tale thats much more rooted in family. Its a story that takes place in a semisimilar world and has a hero whose passion is singing and playing the guitar.
Im glad to say that besides focusing on music and honoring the day of the dead, similarities ended between the two movies. Do you think coco seems too similar to the book of life. Coco seems to draw more inspiration from pixars own ratatouille and hayao miyazakis spirited away than the book of life. Theres concern in the film community that coco and the book of life are twin movies. Adrian nicole leblancs book, random family, published in 2003, was the product of more than eleven years of immersive reporting.
The book of life comparisons are a little too close for comfort, they say. Im almost always listening to the soundtrack, i have an allover print tank top of manolo and maria, and i have a manolo pop on my counter. Perhaps the only difference is the fact the latter has a romantic. The book of life 2 2020 yify download movie torrent hd. Should we be upset at the similarity between the films or is there a reason to celebrate them both. Ultimately, coco is a fantastic movie worthy of the pixardisney brand which every family should enjoy. When movies are twinning, screen rant explains that two.
In 2014, stop motion film the book of life was released and my only regret is not seeing it on the big screen. Once you know the whole story, pretty much everything. The teaser trailer looked interesting and beautiful, but some fans of another day of the dead animation are a little pissed off. Jun 16, 2017 the book of life vs coco thing does not exist in our dojo. This movie came out in 2014 and centered on a protagonist, manolo, who loved playing music, but was forbidden to play by his family. Top ten differences between pixars coco and reel fxs book of life 4 2. Mar 02, 2018 the book of life was more like cultural appropriation where as coco was cultural appreciation most of the characters in coco looked either indigenous or mestizo and was much more accurate then the book of life and to say that the book of life was made by a real mexican and coco wasnt is absurd. Coco looks like its a boy and his dog heros journey, whereas the book of life was love triangle questdriven fare. Nov 27, 2017 most of the book of life is told as if the characters are puppets and so their proportions reflect this and they can look a little goofy. Nov 22, 2017 theres concern in the film community that coco and the book of life are twin movies. As obvious and familiar as this thematic territory can be, coco deals with it tenderly and sweetly, in ways that will send audiences young and old out with a song in their.
Early last year the speculation began that coco looked very much like foxs 2014 film, the book of life. Now that coco is finally out in the world, it can be said plainly. Pixars coco called ripoff by angry fans of similar day of. Coco, the latest pixar movie, has been accused by some fans as being a. What are some of the main differences between the life of. Aug 31, 2017 similarities between coco and the book of life joys asia. Similarities between coco and the book of life joys asia. Mar 17, 2017 the other movie that it got compared to is 20th century foxs the book of life, where both share similarities in setting, music and culture, which is why it is too glaring not to notice. Pixars acclaimed adventure coco from 2017 would later run into controversy for its plot similarities to the book of life, though jorge gutierrez would profess his excitement for the lee unkrich directed movie.
When the trailer for pixars upcoming coco were released people were quick to point out the similarities. While the movies are completely different in plot coco centering around tradition, family, and legacy and the book of life centered on love, bravery, and courage, the similarities in animation come from concepts already embedded in mexican culture. Coco vs the book of life an animated film comparison by david. Lets look at what the book of life and coco actually have in common. Pixars coco called ripoff by angry fans of similar day of the dead. Coco vs the book of life an animated film comparison by. The book of life is waaaay too colorful, its a caricature of mexican culture, and i know its supposed to lookfeel like that but that style is not my cup of tea. Disneypixars coco and reel fxs the book of life both take place on. So instead, ill eschew technical comparisons for ones considering the writing, the music, the visuals, and the characters. Should we be upset of cocos similarity to the book of life. This was the first time the book of life has gotten any mainstream attention but it seems. I heard a lot of people praise book of life when coco was coming out, and i can see why now, because there are a number of thematic and story similarities between the two. I will start by summarizing the story of each movie, then i will list the similarities and the differences, then i will compare specifically their representation of the day of the dead and their use of music.
It does pretty good overall and is well liked by audiences and critics alike. The guitar or passion of music this is here in both movie. Pixars coco is a musical about the day of the dead and it will be the first from the studio with the lead being a person of color. Does pixars coco owe its success to the book of life. Jan 28, 2018 the book of life is a love story, while coco is a story about family. I enjoyed the book of life, and had low expectations for coco in comparison. Coco s animation is so strikingly similar to that of the book of life that its impossible not to imagine coco s animators mining the previous film for concept art. Coco, since its release, has seen widespread success across the u. Coco is pixars latest film, and its first teaser shows a lot to be excited for. Pixars acclaimed adventure coco from 2017 would later run into controversy for its plot similarities to the book of life, though jorge gutierrez would profess his excitement for the lee unkrich directed the movie.
The other movie that it got compared to is 20th century foxs the book of life, where both share similarities in setting, music and culture, which is why it is too glaring not to notice. Coco was announced in 2012, right before the book of life started production, and the latter had been in the works in some form or another since as early as 2001. Theres not a lot of similarity to the story of coco and the book of life. As for the similarities with jorge gutierrezs the book of life. The book and film versions of life of pi both present the journey of a young man and a bengal tiger across the ocean in a lifeboat. Should we be upset of coco s similarity to the book of life. But i adore i love you too much diego lunas singing voice is lovely and the apology song is pretty good as well. The book of life is an animated movie directed and written by jorge r. Beginning in 1990, when leblanc wrote about the trial of.
Despite similarities to foxs 2014 the book of life, coco also takes a positive cultural step for mainstream american entertainment, with its alllatino voice cast. Pixar dropped the trailer for their next film coco. Ever since pixar announced coco, a movie inspired by the mexican day of the dead celebration, comparisons to reel fxs 2014 film the book of life seemed inevitable. The truth is no disrespect to the movie or the people who made it the book of life is enjoyable and relatable, not a cultural staple. If you look closer at the trailer, youll realize that there a few differences between the movieslike coco actually being alive when going into the land of the dead, and the way the place operates compared to bol. Is pixars coco really a ripoff of book of the life. Where do you stand on the debate between coco and the book of life, and do you have to pick side when two similar movies come out. Coco is different than any of the other pixar and disney movies from the past. Should we give disneys coco a chance or is it a book of life. While i may be biased because i loved the book of life, coco was a whole other thing by itself. Sure, the book of life already delved into this stuff, but with a holiday like this, theres bound to be similarities in the ideas. Nov 08, 2017 now that coco is finally out in the world, it can be said plainly. Coco is a 2017 american 3d computeranimated musical fantasy film produced by pixar animation studios and released by walt disney pictures. Jan 21, 2018 early last year the speculation began that coco looked very much like foxs 2014 film, the book of life.
Top 10 differencessimilarities between the book of life and coco. I cried during the last 30 minutes of coco might have been longer and i really felt along with the characters. Domestic box office comparison between the book of life 2014 and coco 2017 where data and the movie business meet follow us on. So lets discuss the similarities between coco and the book of life. Mar 31, 2016 i saw the trailer for coco, then i heard about the controversy, so i went out and bought the book of life to check it out. What is the difference between coco and the book of life. Still, you cant ignore the obvious similarities of the films. Movie fans have been arguing on social media over whether or not pixars latest is in. If youve seen coco and the book of life, youve surely noticed some of the similarities. Book of life fans are calling out pixars coco for being a.
Top 10 differencessimilarities between the book of life. Stop comparing coco and the book of life her campus. I might be sounding a little negative and hard on the film so let me say something i really liked about it. Coco is pixar s new film surrounding day of the dead a copy the book of life art world coco chanel the. Pretty nifty filmit got a few chuckles and a few tears out of me. Thats not a knock against book of life, i enjoyed the movie.
What are some of the main differences between the life of pi. This setting actually made the film really enjoyable to watch because there were so many colorful eye candies. And just today i saw the trailer for coco and immediately thought of the book of life. When movies are twinning, screen rant explains that two films, with similar plot lines are released around.
The book of life is from 20th century fox and was released in 2014. Coco vs the book of life whats better 2018 hd youtube. The music, the colors, the animation style, loved all of it. For those who feel like it had an uncanny resemblance to another day of the dead film, apparently there are a lot of people who think so too. Long noted for its similarities to the 2014 jorge gutierrez film, the book of life, the trailer for coco hasnt assuaged fears that its a ripoff.
The movie is a day of the dead themed musical as well, using. Most of the book of life is told as if the characters are puppets and so their proportions reflect this and they can look a little goofy. Because of their similar aesthetic styles and musical themes, the two movies have been compared relentlessly. Given the beloved status of the cat concerto and rhapsody rabbit after 70 years, its almost assured that the existence of both films will be to their mutual benefit. It gave me a bit of a funny feeling that a movie i loved so much seemed to be somewhat copied only a few years later. Were you able to spot the similarities while watching. The book of life is a love story, while coco is a story about family. The book of life is just as entertaining but coco will pull at your heart strings.
The book of life vs coco thing does not exist in our dojo. It can easily accommodate two films with a similar basis, and given the three year difference between the book of life and coco, thats even more likely. To put it bluntly in my opinion coco is simply a better film than book of life period. Coco is much more of a spiritual journey than the book of life. Pixars coco called ripoff by angry fans of similar day. Pixars coco may not be a ripoff, though, as it was pitched in 2010 and first announced in 2012, two years before the book of life was released and a few months before it was announced. The book of life is a 2014 american 3d computeranimated musical fantasy adventure comedy film produced by reel fx creative studios and distributed by 20th century fox. I did not think i would love this movie so much, but im obsessed with it. While the book of life is a wonderful, feelgood movie about love, family, and tradition that takes place during the day of the dead, coco is a film truly about the holiday that accurately captures the emotions and essence of a tradition that has strived for centuries to keep people connected to their familia. Similarities between coco and the book of life joys of asia. The book of life is a love story that explores the importance of bravery and confronting ones own fears, while coco is a coming of age tale thats much more rooted in family. While we still think that both movies stand on their own, separately important merits, a quick visual. Jan 19, 2018 the book of life is just as entertaining but coco will pull at your heart strings.
48 430 1071 64 1357 639 280 1108 1562 608 300 811 688 496 1017 120 1345 1516 1385 1035 875 1394 311 1211 1000 309 1025 210 447 974 350 1391 1123 956 7 1499 1537 755 270 1205 1155 215 1031 103 84 636 440